Feng Shui: A Comprehensive Review of its Effectiveness Based on Evaluation Studies

Authors

  • Spela KryZanowski Faculty of Design, University of Primorska Slovenia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31695/IJASRE.2021.34103

Keywords:

Feng Shui, Scientific Evaluation, Comparative Studies, Experimental Studies

Abstract

After five decades of its presence in the Western European space, the architectural profession, regardless of the popularity of feng shui, has never systematically declared itself about this phenomenon. This is a professional problem. It is equally absurd to dismiss feng shui as a bunch of superstitious nonsense without properly scientifically researching it, as well as its detailed study following all Western science standards, without asking, at least once, whether the Fengshui recommendations have the effect they promise, and if so, which and why. To answer this question an in-depth analysis of scientific articles on feng shui was performed.

Evaluation studies found were divided into three groups: comparative studies where the effectiveness of fengshui's recommendations is not directly verified by field research, but compared with findings in other areas of science; field experimental studies that examine the actual effectiveness of selected feng shui recommendations, through a real or virtual environment, engaging participants and sometimes a control protocol and studies of living quality evaluation systems with feng shui recommendations. Based on the results of the studies analysed it can be concluded, that between the feng shui school of form, environmental psychology and sustainable design principles there are certain similarities, which some researchers confirm with a higher or a lower degree of correlation and statistical significance. On the other side, one of the fundamental concepts of feng shui, namely the concept of life energy qi, remains poorly researched. The conclusion is, that the greatest potential of feng shui for contemporary architecture is not so much in the practical application of its techniques and recommendations, as much of this is already included in everyday design practice, but in its philosophical and conceptual foundations. They can encourage architects to re-think spatial concepts and, if necessary, to change established spatial paradigms.

References

Feng shui (1999): »Feng shui«, Haeuser, 6, 10-11.

See e.g. Wu, W. Y., Yau, O. H. M., Lu, H. Y. (2012): »Feng Shui Principles in Residential Housing Selection«, Psychology & Marketing, 29, 7, 502 – 518; Peng, Y. S., Hsiung, H. H., Chen, K. H. (2012):« The Level of Concern about Feng Shui in House Purchasing: The Impacts of Self Efficacy, Superstition and the Big Five Personality Traits«, Psychology & Marketing, 29, 7, 519 – 530; So, A. T. P., Lu, J. W. Z. (2001): »Natural ventilation Design by Computational Fluid Dynamics - A Feng-shui Approach«, Architectural Science Review, 44, 1, 61 – 69.

Bruun, O. (2008): An Introduction to Feng Shui. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Paton, M. (2007): »Fengshui: A Continuation of 'Art of Swindlers'?«, Journal of Chinese Philosophy, 34, 3, 427 – 445. Available at: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1540-6253.2007.00427.x (30.11.2018)

See note 3.

Paton, M. (2009): »Feng Shui the Energy of the Land«, in Mak, M. Y.,So, A. T. (ed) (2009): Research in Scientific Feng Shui and the Built Environment, City University of Hong Kong Press, 45 – 64.

See note 3.

See e.g. Yu in Moran, E., Yu, J., Biktashev, V. (2005): »The Complete Idiot's Guide to Feng Shui«. New York, Third edition.Alpha books.

Chan, W. T. (1963): A Source Book in Chinese Philosophy. New Jersey, Princeton University Press in Mak, M. Y., So, A. T. (2011): Scientific Feng Shui for the Built Environment. Hong Kong, City University of Hong Kong Press: 29.

Lip published one of the first feng shui manuals in 1979: Lip, E. (1979): Chinese Geomancy. Singapore, Times Books International.

Bramble, C. (2003): Architect's guide to feng shui. Oxford, Architectural Press.

See e.g. Yan, X., Lu, F., Jiang, H., Wu, X., Cao, W., Xia, Z., Wang, J., Shen, H., Dao, M., Lin, H., Zhu, R. (2002): »Certain Physical Manifestation and Effects of External Qi of Yan Xin Life Science Technology«, Journal of Scientific Exploration, 16, 3, 381 – 411; Yan, X., Shen, H., Jiang, H. in Zhang, C. (2006): »External Qi of Yan Xin Qigong Differentially regulates the Akt and Extracellular Signal Regulated Kinase Pathways and is Cytotoxic to Cancer Cells but not to Normal Cells«, Journal of Biochemistry & cell biology, 38, 12, 2102 – 2113.

Lu, Z. (1997): Scientific Qigong Exploration: The Wonders and Mysteries of Qi. Malvern, Pennsylvania, Amber Leaf Press.

Matthews, M. (2019): Feng Shui: Teaching about Science and Pseudoscience. Springer International Publishing: 288.

See e.g. Shermer, M. (ed.), Linse, P. (cont.ed.) (2002): The Skeptic Encyclopedia of Pseudoscience. Santa Barbara, ABC-CLIO.

Kryžanowski, Š. (2012): Feng shui, filozofija prostora in psihologija bivanja. Ljubljana, Mladinska knjiga.

Bowen, G. (2009): »Document Analysis as a Qualitative Research Method«, Qualitative Research Journal, 9, 2, 27 – 40.

Juneja, P. (2020): »Desk Research – methodology and Techniques«. Available at: https://www.managementstudyguide.com/desk-research.htm (Accessed 15.9.2020)

Creswell, J. W. (2009): Research Design: Qualitative, quantitative and Mixed Methods Approaches. Los Angeles, SAGE

Xu, Z. (2004): »Geomancy Theories and Behavior Psychology«, Journal of Hefei University of Technology (Social Sciences). Available at: http://en.cnki.com.cn/Article_en/CJFDTOTAL (Accessed 1.3.2018).

Bonaiuto, M., Bilotta, E., Stolfa, A. (2010): »Feng shui and Environmental Psychology: A Critical Comparison«, Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 27, 1, 23 – 34.

Kryžanowski, Š. (2019): »Comparative Analysis Between Selected Recommendations of Fengshui School of Form, Pattern Language of Alexander and Colleagues and Findings of Environmental Psychology”, Urbani izziv, 30, 2, 124 – 134.

Yoon, H. K. (1980): »The Image of Nature in Geomancy«, Geo Journal, 4, 4, 341 – 348.

Shin, K. S., Lim, Y. H. (2013): »A Study on Passive Elements of Han – Ok on a Standpoint of Feng Shui Focused on the Old House of Yang Dong Town «, Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korean Planning & Design, 29, 12 – 20.

Lau, S. S. Y., Garcia, R., Ou, Y., Kwok, M. M., Zhang, Y., Shen, S. J., Namba, H. (2005): »Sustainable Design and Its Simplest Form: Lessons from the Living Villages of Fujian Rammed Earth Houses”, Structural Survey, 2005, 23, 371-385. Available at: https://hub.hku.hk/handle/10722/149372 (Accessed 28.2.2019)

Zhao, Y., Chen, K., Li, P. (2018): »Ecological Design Concept of Traditional Architecture«, International Core Journal 0f Engineering, 4, 4, 240 – 244.

Choe, S. J., Han, S. H. (2019): Applicability of Feng Shui Thoughts for Sustainable Space Planning and Evaluation in Korea Verified Using Three-Dimensional Digital Mapping and Simulations«, Sustainability, 11, 20, 55 – 78.

Mak, M. Y., Ge, J. X. (2010): »Sustainable Design and Feng Shui: A Case Study of an Office Building in Sydney«. Available at: https://www.irbnet.de/daten/iconda/CIB_DC24655.pdf (Accessed 28. 2. 2019)

Mak, M. Y., Ge, J. X. (2012): »Feng Shui: A Chinese Perspective of Sustainability«, Global Chinese Real Estate Congress Annual Conference, Macau. Available at: https://www.um.edu.mo/fba/gcrec2012/83974183/12203-Mak.pdf (Accessed 28. 2. 2019)

Mak, M. Y. (2017): »An Empirical Study of Modern Sustainable Office Buildings in Sydney from the Feng Shui Perspective«, Academic Journal of Feng Shui, 1st Symposium Oceania, University of Technology Sydney, 13. – 14. maj 2017. Available at: http://ajofengshui.co.nf/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Mak_Michael_2017_Empirical_Modern_Sustainable_L_PA.pdf (Accessed 28. 2. 2019)

Dong, W., Zuehli, R. (2009): »The Comparison and Contrast Between Green Design and Feng Shui«, in Mak, M. Y., So, A. T. (ed) (2009): Research in Scientific Feng Shui and the Built Environment, City University of Hong Kong Press, 209 – 230.

Mak, M. Y., Hui, Y. (2018): »West Kowloon Station in Hong Kong: an exemplar case of sustainable Design and scientific Feng Shui Applications for High-speed rail Stations«, Academic Journal of Feng Shui, 2, 1. Abstract available at: https://nova.newcastle.edu.au/vital/access/manager/Repository/uon:35578?view=null&f0=sm_relation%3A%22Academic+Journal+of+Feng+Shui+Vol.+2%2C+Issue+1%22&sort=null (Accessed 15.9.2020)

Octavia, L., Gunawan, T. (2014): »Feng shui in Modern House Design: Searching for the Rationale and Possible Impacts Assesment«, Journal of Architecture and Built Environment, 41, 1, 43 – 50.

Spear, W. (1995): Feng Shui Made It Easy, Designing Your Live With the Ancient Art of Placement. Boston, Harper Collins Publishers.

Han, K. T., Amita, S. (1996): »An Empirical Study of Feng shui in Landscape«, Environments, 23, 3, 36 – 49.

Han, K. T. (2004): »A Preliminary Study of Luan Tou Feng shui Landscapes and Psychological Reactions«, Journal of Psychology in Chinese Societies, 5, 2, 289 - .

Um, J. S. (2009): »Exploring Spatially Prioritized Parameters of Feng-Shui from Tomb Footprint«, International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 23, 4, 513 – 529.

Lynch, E. S. (2003): Feng Shui as a Site Design Tool: Assessing Conditions of Human Comfort in Urban Places. Master's Theses, University of Arizona, Architecture and Landscape Architecture.

Mak, M. Y., Ng, S. T. (2005): »The Art and Science of Feng Shui – A Study on Architects' Perception«, Building and Environment, 40, 3, 427 – 434.

Hong, W.T., Abdul-Rahman, H., Wang, C. (2017): »Are Feng shui Bedroom Rules Practical from the Architectural Perspective?« Academic Journal of Feng Shui, 1st Symposium Oceania, University of Technology Sydney, 13. – 14. maj 2017. Available at: http://ajofengshui.co.nf/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Hong_Wan_Thing_2017_Bedroom_Rules_L_P.pdf (Accessed 1.3.2018).

So, A. T. P., Lu, J. W. Z. (2001): »Natural ventilation Design by Computational Fluid Dynamics - A Feng-shui Approach«, Architectural Science Review, 44, 1, 61 – 69.

Kryžanowski, Š. (2019b): Feng Shui and Apperception of Space: An Overview of Scientific Research and a Filed Research of Efficiency of Recommendations. Ph.D. dissertation. Ljubljana, ISH, Alma Mater Europaea, Institutum Studiorum Humanitatis –Faculty of Postgraduate Humanities. (In Slovene)

Kryžanowski, Š. (2021): »Impact of Feng Shui Bedrooms on Self-Assessed Sleep and Well-Being: A Randomized Double-Blind Field Research with Instrumental Biocommunication.« southeast European Journal of Architecture and Design, 1–8.

Poulston, J., Bennett, R. (2012): »Feng Shui, Fact and Fiction: An Exploratory Study«. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jill_Poulston/publication/235260228_Fact_fiction_and_feng_shui_An_exploratory_study/links/5669e80308ae62b05f027175/Fact-fiction-and-feng-shui-An-exploratory-study.pdf (Accessed 12.4.2018).

See e.g. Ulrich, R. (1984): »View through a window may influence recovery from surgery«, Science, 224, 420 – 421.

Bazley, C., Vink, P., Montgomery, J., Hedge, A. (2016): »Interior Effects on Comfort in Healthcare Waiting Areas«, Work, 54, 4, 791 – 806.

Charles, R., Glover, S., Bauchmueller, K., Wood, D. (2017): »Feng shui And Emotional Response in the Critical care Environment (FARCE) study«, Anaesthesia, 72, 1528 – 1531.

Pheng, L. S., Xiaopeng, D., Ting, Q. L. (2012): »Assimilating Total Building Performance Mandates with Chinese Geomancy Principles and Scenarios«, Facilities, 30, 13/14, 558 – 589.

Chang, P. T., Lee, J. H., Hung, K. C., Tsai, J. T., Perng, C. (2009): »Applying Fuzzy Weighted Average Approach to Evaluate Office Layouts with Feng Shui Consideration«, Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 50, 1514 – 1537.

See e.g. Wong, F. T. (2009): »An Assessment into the Basics of Eight Mansions Feng Shui Theory«, in Mak, M. Y., So, A. T. (ed) (2009): Research in Scientific Feng Shui and the Built Environment. Hong Kong, City University of Hong Kong Press, 27 – 44.

Bruun, O. (2003): Feng Shui in China, Geomantic Divination Between State Orthodoxy and Popular Religion. Honolulu, University of Hawai Press.

See e.g. Augustin, S., 2009: Place advantage. Hoboken, New Jersey, Wiley&Sons: 10.

See e.g. Hwangbo, A. B. (1999): »A New Millennium and Feng Shui«, The Journal of Architecture, 4, 191 – 198.

See e.g. Tsang, E. W. K. (2004): »Toward a Scientific Inquiry Into Superstitious Business Decision Making«, Organization Studies. Dostopno prek: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0170840604042405 (23.3.2017); Chang, W. L. Lii, P. (2010): “Feng Shui and Its Role in Corporate Image and reputation: A Review From Business and Cultural Perspectives”, Journal of Architecture and Planning Research, 27, 1, 1 – 13.

See e.g. Yeo, S. S., Meiser, B., Barlow – Stewart, K., Goldstein, D., Tucker, K., Eisenbruch, M. (2004): »Understanding Community Beliefs of Chinese Australians about Cancer: Initial Insights Using an Ethnographic Approach«, Psycho-Oncology, 14, 3, 174 – 186; Chui, Y. Y., Donoghue, J., Chenoweth, L. (2005): »Responses to Advanced Cancer: Chinese Australians«, Journal of Advanced Nursing, 52, 5, 498 – 507.

See e.g. Kelley, H. H. (1992): »Common Sense Psychology and Scientific Psychology«, Annual Review of Psychology, 43, 1 – 23.

Alexander, C. (2002a): The Phenomenon of Life – The Nature of Order, 1. Berkeley, Center for Environmental Structure; 64. Alexander, C. (2002b): The Process of Creating Life – The Nature of Order, 2. Berkeley, Center for Environmental Structure; Alexander, C. (2004): The Luminous Ground – The Nature of Order, 4. Berkeley, Center for Environmental Structure; Alexander, C. (2005): A Vision of a Living World – The Nature of Order, 3. Berkeley, Center for Environmental Structure

Downloads

Published

2021-11-18

How to Cite

Spela KryZanowski. (2021). Feng Shui: A Comprehensive Review of its Effectiveness Based on Evaluation Studies. International Journal of Advances in Scientific Research and Engineering (IJASRE), ISSN:2454-8006, DOI: 10.31695/IJASRE, 7(11), 61–71. https://doi.org/10.31695/IJASRE.2021.34103

Issue

Section

Articles